Sunday, June 1, 2025

A Rabbi, a Journalist, and the Bates Motel

 Prompt - Crossword Clues (400 words): Get yourself a newspaper and go to the crossword puzzle. Take two or three of the crossword clues and formulate a story around them.  For example: From the New York Times - In Tahitian it means “good.” From the Guardian - Blue swallow feathers fell from above.

***

    “Jesus, just look at him!” My college roommate’s ex-girlfriend exclaimed when she saw the rabbi walking down the sidewalk toward the hotel where we were to meet. In the 10 years since we graduated, she still seemed surprised when people didn’t look the way she expected.

    I glanced at the elderly rabbi. Side curls, a bushy beard, the typical outfit of a white shirt, and a dark coat and pants.  It was winter, so he’d donned a big parka over his long coat, and a fur hat covered his yarmulka. I noticed that he was a little stooped, but everything else seemed pretty normal.  “Yeah? He’s a rabbi. What did you expect?”

    “I dunno.  But I wasn’t expecting a hirsute himalayan.”  She was grinning slightly, expecting me to rise to the bait. I debated letting it go but decided to give her what she wanted.

    “Kate, Seriously, did you just call him an abominable snowman?”

    She grinned, then cracked up. “I might have.  He’s awfully hairy, and that fur hat and all.”

    I sighed.  “Remember, don’t offer to shake hands. Orthodox Jews don’t touch the opposite sex, unless they are family.”

    “Yeah, yeah, I got it.” Kate said. She was a journalist, and in public, she knew how to use tact … when she wanted to. When she was among friends, though, tact went out the window.  

    “Rebbe Cohen agreed to talk to you, but he’s Hasid, so it will be very easy for a shiksa like you to make him uncomfortable.  Be polite.”

    “Of course.” She rolled her eyes at my worries.  “Does he know that I’m also going to interview … Holy Mary Mother of Jesus … what’s a mosque holy man called again?” She looked frustrated this time.

    “Imam, and yes, he does.”

    “Ever since the explosion, I lose words.”  She was definitely not smiling.

    “Oh.” I’d forgotten that the embassy where she was staying on her last assignment had been bombed. She’d been in a part of the building that had remained standing, but the shockwave had knocked her into a wall.  The doctors thought she’d recover, at least physically.  I wasn’t so sure about the PTSD.  “Sorry.”

    “No worries.  So, why does he want to meet at the Bates Motel?”  We’d pulled into the parking lot of a rundown inn.  She was right. It did look like a creepy film motel.

    “Because it’s neutral ground. An Orthodox rabbi would prefer not to have a Gentile in his house.  But, this is important to the community, so he found a way to make it work.”

    We locked the car and went inside.  Instead of the brash, tactless friend, she had assumed the role of a professional and strode up to the rabbi. “Rebbe Cohen, my name is Kate Smithson with the Washington Post. Thank you for meeting with me.” She nodded and did not extend her hand.

    The rabbi smiled warmly at her, and spoke loudly to be heard over the Metro squealing to a stop nearby. “Of course, my child.  It’s not every day that the imam of a local mosque organizes safety patrols to protect Jews from antisemites.  He is a brother to us. The least I can do in return is to normalize the idea that not only are we all Americans, we are all sons and daughters of Abraham.”

--April 18, 2021

***

Notes: 

  • Clues came from Washington Post crossword from April 18, 2021. I set the piece in D.C. because of that.
  • I used 3 clues: 70. Hirsute Himalayan, 73. Mosque Holy Man, and 109. Creepy film motel.
  • I wildly missed my 400 word goal; it's 550 words. It also doesn't feel like a stand-alone story, and feels like the introduction to something longer.

1945: Grandpa Arthur's 2nd daughter is born at a hospital in Valence, France.

Source: Memories of Drôme. Photo from the late 1930s.
Polyclinique de Notre-Dame Auxiliatrice, the hospital
where my mother was born.

        Grandpa Arthur told me a little bit about Mom's birth back in 1988 when I recorded his stories:

     Was it a hospital or maternité? I forgot. I think it was a hospital. Lillian was born in a maternité. It was only for birth. But this was a hospital. So when it became apparent she was supposed to go to the hospital, I went and got the car and drove her to the hospital ... and the hospital was not heated, by lack of fuel. It was freezing in every room. The only heating was in surgeries and delivery rooms. Otherwise it was not ...  [brrrr] ... shiver. So when I picked up Roma in the car to get her to the delivery room. How cold the delivery room was? Well, the doctor asked me to step out ...  And I was cold. I claimed I suffered more than Roma. Roma is laughing at that, but she was not cold, and I was. But all right. What else you want to know? The baby came, it was a daughter, my second daughter and very lovely. 


    You can read a rough draft of that chapter here, but keep in mind that it's definitely rough, and has been revised since I posted it (and will be revised further still).

    Anyway, a couple of weeks ago, I had the following conversation with my mom:

Me: Can I get a photocopy of your birth certificate?

Mom: Why do you need that?

Me: Because sometimes there are clues on the document that will help with the story.

Mom: What sort of clues?

Me: Well, on Lilly's document, it listed the names and ages of the two out-of-work guys Grandpa paid to be his witnesses. It also provided the street address of the clinic where Lilly was born, and listed their home address, which allowed me to map out a plausible route for Grandpa to follow on the day of the invasion.  

Mom: Well, it's in the safe deposit box; give me a few days.    

    Mom's birth certificate proved to be just as useful as Lilly's. It:

  • Corroborated their then-current address in Valence.
  • Provided the street address of the building where my mother was born (44 Rue Amblard, Valence France), which confirms that it was indeed a hospital, and not a maternity clinic.  
  • Listed the time of day she was born (the wee hours!).
  • Cost my grandpa 2.50 francs in paperwork fees, and another 3 or so francs in other taxes.

    With the help of my historian friend in France, I learned that the building was constructed in 1935, and was originally called the "Polyclinique de Notre-Dame Auxiliatrice" (In English, "Notre-Dame Auxiliary Hospital"). 

    It was a public hospital at the time, but today it is privately-operated as a retirement home called La Maison de L'Automn ("the Autumn House"):

La Maison de L'Automn, today.
Source: MDRS.