- IMDB link: Sinners
- Tagline: "Trying to leave their troubled lives behind, twin brothers return to their hometown to start again, only to discover that an even greater evil is waiting to welcome them back."
- My Best Picture Project
Ohmygod. This movie was spectacular. Seriously, do yourself a favor, and if you haven't seen it, pop some popcorn, grab a beer, and sit back and enjoy the story, the creepiness, the acting, and most of all, the music. This was a horror movie with history, symbolism, and unexpected themes; a near-perfect example of entertaining and riveting storytelling that tells a simple story with complex and multi-layered meaning.
Now, how to talk about this movie without giving too much away?
Director Ryan Coogler set the movie in 1932, and the main characters are WWI veterans-turned-Capone gangsters-turned-southern-speakeasy owners. Michael B. Jordan plays twins Smoke and Stack (get it?) who return home after years away, intending to open their own club. It's sometimes hard to tell the twins apart -- one memory hint that might help as you watch the movie is that Smoke wears a blue hat (smoke is often blue), and Stack wears a red hat (smoke stacks are often made of red brick). Anyway, they enlist their cousin, a gifted blues musician, to be their opening act.
From there, everything goes to hell, as the movie sneaks its way from a wonderfully moody period drama into a monster movie with carefully crafted visuals and hints that observe all the rules of vampire lore (though it does speed up the turning process, from hours to minutes). Coogler also sneaks in other lore (hoodoo), and visual homages to other monsters - there is a scene of the undead singing that reminds me a little of Michael Jackson's Thriller video.
The acting is excellent. As always, Jordan creates a powerful presence on screen, but the entire cast is stand-out, including Delroy Lindo, Miles Caton, Halee Steinfeld, Li Jun Li, Jayme Lawson, and Wunmi Mosaku They rounded out the story nicely.
I also want to call out Jack O'Connell, who played an important villain; he slipped between Irish and a peckerwood accents seamlessly (it makes sense, I swear). I kept wondering how the actor could do such a perfect Irish accent, but then I found out that it's his natural accent, and the convincing, skillful part was the rural American South in his voice. The movie also uses Irish history as an important theme. The main vampire is Irish. They drink Irish beer at the speakeasy, and it's more than just a thematic element; it's also a plot device (I can't say much about that - that would give too much away). It goes even deeper; Bram Stoker, the author of Dracula, was Irish, but more than that, Irish history mirrors African American history very closely. Coogler layers in the parallels and connections beautifully. Even small details like inclusion of the Choctaw are important (the Choctaw raised money to help the Irish during the Irish potato famine of the 1850s. 170 years later, the Irish raised money to help Native American communities hardest hit by the COVID epidemic).
There were only a few minor things that bothered me: one that isn't really the movie's fault, and two that are. Not the movie's fault: I have some hearing loss, so dialogue tracks in movies need to be really clear for me to understand them, and I'm having more and more difficulty with accents other than my own as I get older. Between the rural Southern dialects and the fact that Michael B. Jordan doesn't move his lips much in this movie (this isn't true in his other roles, so I think it was a character trait that fits the character), I had some difficulty understanding what people were saying. I turned on subtitles, and that solved the issue.
Now for the two that ARE the movie's fault - movies today are being made with muddy dialog tracks, and it seems to be a deliberate stylistic trend; I think the moviemakers are trying to be realistic and immersive. That is true of this movie. I know it's not just my hearing - I can turn on movies made 30 and 40 years ago and have no trouble understanding them, but I do have difficulty with a lot of modern dialogue tracks, regardless of dialect (the TV show Coroner, which takes place in Ontario, is a particularly egregious example). The rest of the sound design is excellent, though.
The final problem is that the credits start to roll ... but the movie is not over. There is a VERY extended outtake with another 5 or so minutes of movie that you should absolutely not miss. As we were turning off the movie, my daughter noticed that there were many more minutes left, so we went back in, and I'm glad we did. So, note to Mr. Coogler: don't start rolling the credits until the movie is genuinely over, particularly in non-Marvel movies like this one, where outtakes aren't expected. It's only because of my daughter's quick thinking that we didn't miss the real ending of the movie. The outtake isn't just a small easter egg; Buddy Guy, the real-life blues musician, plays an important part.
One final note. The tagline includes the phrase, "an even greater evil is waiting to welcome them back." Chris and I gave the movie a much higher "important message" score than we might normally give a monster flick because it addresses the virulent racism of the early 1930s.
(Pithy Reviews; and Rankings* out of 10 nominees):
- Sinners (Southern Gothic Vampires Sing the Blues; Cathy: 1, Chris: 1)
- F1: The Movie (Mesmerizing Top Gun for Formula 1 Fans; Cathy: 2, Chris 2)
* Rankings can change.